Single IRB Concerns Include IT Limitations, Process Variations
Formats
Happy Holidays from the Clinical Trials Transformation Initiative
CTTI ushered in 2021 with a new vision for Transforming Trials 2030 – one that requires cross-system collaboration from the entire research and healthcare community to create true and lasting change for better clinical trials by 2030.
On behalf of everyone at CTTI, thank you for joining us on this ambitious journey this year. Your contributions to pushing the boundaries for what can be done in clinical research and your dedication to creating improvements across the clinical trials community are truly making an impact. We are grateful for the opportunity to work with you and are proud to have your support.
Some of the accomplishments you have made possible in 2021 include:
- Making significant headway in creating solutions to support the first of the five pillars of Transforming Trials 2030 – “Patient-Centered & Easily Accessible” – through three key projects:
- Laying the foundations for the other vision pillars including:
- The second pillar – “Fully Integrated into Health Processes” – which is supported by our Trials in Health Care Settings
- The third pillar – “Designed with a Quality Approach” – which is furthered by our convening of global web conferences and developing new case studies.
- The fourth pillar – “Maximally Leveraging All Available Data” – which is being driven by our gov Reporting Challenges project.
- And finally, our efforts to make the HABP/VABP study data publicly available are advancing the fifth pillar – “Improve Public Health.”
- Sharing best practices and learnings from across the clinical trials community by:
- Launching our new Building Better Trials: Case Study Exchange, featuring more than 40 case studies on best practices and examples of CTTI’s work in action;
- Collaborating with the Duke-Margolis Center for Health Policy and FasterCures on a public summit on using master protocols in COVID-19 trials, and with the Digital Medicine Society (DiMe) and TransCelerate on a three-part webinar series on novel digital endpoints and;
- Hosting a public webinar on COVID-19 treatment trials with clinical research experts.
As we look to 2022 under the leadership of our passionate new leader, Executive Director Sally Okun, we are excited to celebrate 15 years of increasing the quality and efficiency of clinical trials through the future-facing lens of our 2030 vision. This ambitious pursuit is the ultimate challenge, but also presents the biggest opportunity and reward.
As Socrates said, “The secret of change is to focus all of your energy, not on fighting the old, but on building the new.”
We look forward to “building the new” with you in 2022 and to making great strides toward achieving the audacious goal of transforming trials by 2030.
Best wishes for health and happiness to you and your families over this festive season and in the new year!
CTTI Holds Meeting to Discuss the Systemic Changes Needed to Increase Diversity in Clinical Trials
The Clinical Trials Transformation Initiative (CTTI) held a two-day multi-stakeholder expert meeting on Oct. 12 & 21 to discuss the systemic changes needed to ensure that U.S. clinical trials better meet the needs of diverse populations, including racial minorities, ethnic minorities, and women. At the meeting, leaders and key stakeholders from across the clinical trials ecosystem participated in an engaging forum, informative discussions, and lively breakout sessions that shed more light on new solutions for sharing information and ensuring sufficient resource allocation to diversity, equity, and inclusion initiatives.
Meeting attendees also identified some important themes and identified opportunities to increase diversity in clinical trials:
- The benefits are indisputable. Including a diverse population in clinical trials improves the quality of science, enhances patient trust, increases patient recruitment and retention, and improves clinical care for all patients.
- A culture shift is needed. Organizations need to ingrain diversity, equity, and inclusion initiatives into their portfolio-level strategy and within their overall mission. They should foster bi-directional community partnerships and directly engage patients in the design and planning of clinical trials and diversity efforts from the very beginning.
- This is a full group effort. Increasing diversity in clinical trials is a multi-stakeholder effort that will take all groups working together to achieve goals of clinical trial populations representing the populations who are affected by disease.
- There is important work ahead of us. Meeting attendees provided feedback on CTTI’s draft maturity model, helping to create a better public resource. Suggested additions included a focus on values and guidelines that are generalizable to a wide variety of stakeholders, not just industry stakeholders, and more guidance on how organizations can measure their progress through the maturity model.
CTTI is now using these findings – along with other research results and multi-stakeholder discussions – to develop recommendations and resources for release in early 2022. The project team may host additional webinars focusing on case studies and implementation of resources.
Patient Engagement Collaborative Announces Eight New Members
Today, the U.S. Food and Drug Administration (FDA) and the Clinical Trials Transformation Initiative (CTTI) announced eight newly selected representatives for the Patient Engagement Collaborative (PEC). The group of 16 patients, caregivers, and patient group representatives will meet with the FDA several times a year to discuss topics such as communication, transparency, and the best ways for patients to participate in the FDA’s regulatory discussions about medical products. Those selected to the PEC are expected to serve for two years.
The eight new representatives are:
- Carol Abraham
- Julie Breneiser
- Sneha Dave
- Maria De Leon
- Sharon Lagas
- John Linnell
- James Pantelas
- Traceann Rose
The representatives were selected from more than 100 applications received in response to a Federal Register notice published in July 2021. These new members of the PEC include patients who have personal disease experience, caregivers who have personal experience supporting someone with a health condition, and representatives from patient groups who have direct or indirect disease experience. The selection committee, which included patient advocates, FDA staff from multiple centers, CTTI staff and several outgoing PEC members, worked to identify individuals with diverse perspectives and experiences who could meaningfully contribute and express the patient voice.
“CTTI is delighted to welcome the new members to the PEC and we extend our deepest thanks to those outgoing members for their important service and contributions,” said Sally Okun, CTTI’s executive director. “As CTTI works to advance our vision of Transforming Trials 2030, we anticipate that discussions with the PEC can help us identify opportunities to achieve our first pillar, in particular: ‘to make clinical trials patient-centric and easily accessible’. We can only accomplish this if we are on the journey together with patients.”
The PEC, a collaboration established by FDA and CTTI in 2018, is a group of patient organizations and individual representatives who discuss ways to enhance patient engagement. FDA and CTTI collaborate to involve representatives with a variety of perspectives including patients, caregivers and representatives from diverse patient organizations and communities. The PEC is run by the FDA’s Office of Patient Affairs, which is dedicated to providing an inviting, welcoming and meaningful experience for patient communities to engage with the FDA.
“Understanding patients’ experiences is critical to informing medical product regulation and helping ensure that safe, effective and innovative medical products are available and meet the needs of patients as best as possible for improved quality of life. Learning from patients through the PEC helps the agency uphold its public health mission,” said Andrea Furia-Helms, M.P.H., Director of Patient Affairs, Office of Clinical Policy and Programs, FDA.
Going forward, the PEC will continue the dialogue around how patient perspectives can inform and enhance the clinical trials enterprise. The next cohort of PEC members will identify topics to focus on. Previous topics have included: creating new ways to collaborate with patient communities; making patient engagement more systematic; improving transparency through education and outreach; and enhancing communication between the FDA and patient communities.
The FDA and CTTI wish to thank the outgoing members for their service to the PEC over the past several years:
- Dawn Aldrich
- Christine Brown
- Jeffrey Goldstein
- Melissa Hogan
- Nancy Lenfestey
- Stephanie Monroe
- Theresa Strong
- Dave White
The PEC has worked tirelessly to incorporate the patient voice in the FDA’s medical product regulatory programs. For example, the PEC has:
- Provided enhanced information to patient communities (e.g., for patients webpage).
- Created materials to help patients understand FDA’s mission/roles and patient engagement activities.
- Worked to better understand COVID-19’s impact on clinical trials for other diseases and conditions through informal discussions.
- Worked to understand patient concerns regarding COVID-19 vaccines.
- Met with the European Medicines Agency’s Patients’ and Consumers’ Working Party to exchange ideas around enhancing patient engagement, particularly incorporating youth perspectives.
Since 2008, CTTI has included patient advocates on its Executive Committee, Steering Committee, and project teams and, today, nearly all of its more than 30 sets of evidence-based recommendations and associated frameworks and tools mention inclusion of patients as a critical part of the clinical trials process.
Report Now Available: ICH E6 Guideline for Good Clinical Practice (GCP) – Update on Progress
The report of the public web conference on “ICH E6 Guideline for Good Clinical Practice (GCP) – Update on Progress,” organized by International Council for Harmonisation (ICH) and convened by the Clinical Trials Transformation Initiative (CTTI), is now available. The web conference, which consisted of identical meetings at different times on May 18 & 19 to accommodate a global audience, reached more than 5100 attendees.
The ICH E6 Expert Working Group (EWG) members, who are updating the guideline, presented a video wherein they shared the ICH guideline development process and the approach to updating ICH E6 The video was followed by presentations on the vision and goals for updating the ICH E6 guideline and on lessons learned from public input and stakeholder feedback on the ICH E6 revision process. In the final session, EWG members discussed the draft principles, which were published in April. Key stakeholders closed the web conference by sharing their visions and aspirations for clinical trials.
Check out the recording and the slide decks for each day of the web conference to learn more from the presenters.
For additional information on updating the ICH E6, please refer to the following materials:
- ICH E6 main page (ich.org)
- ICH E6(R3) Concept Paper
- Summary of the ICH E6 engagement proposal
- ICH E6 Good Clinical Practice (GCP) Draft Principles
- CTTI’s Informing the Update of ICH E6 Work
- 2020 CTTI Research & Findings